This question is related to my previous one here. I opened a new question because I think that the root cause is different though. BTW I use MMA 9 on a mac OS X 10.11 (El Capitan).
I put here a minimal example. I define a constant:
const`precisionRate = 10
and a function which uses this constant:
f = Function[x, N[x^2, const`precisionRate]];
when I look at the definition of my function I get as expected:
If I run it I get as expected:
f[2]
(*4.000000000*)
Using it within table also works:
Table[{y, f[y]}, {y, -1, 1, 0.1}]
(*{{-1., 1.}, {-0.9, 0.81}, {-0.8, 0.64}, {-0.7, 0.49}, {-0.6,
0.36}, {-0.5, 0.25}, {-0.4, 0.16}, {-0.3, 0.09}, {-0.2,
0.04}, {-0.1, 0.01}, {0., 0.}, {0.1, 0.01}, {0.2, 0.04}, {0.3,
0.09}, {0.4, 0.16}, {0.5, 0.25}, {0.6, 0.36}, {0.7, 0.49}, {0.8,
0.64}, {0.9, 0.81}, {1., 1.}}*)
But when I run:
ParallelTable[{y, f[y]}, {y, -1, 1, 0.1}]
I get an error (from each kernel separately of course):
Why does prallelization screw this up?
Answer
I am not 100% comfortable about this aspect of parallelization, so this is not going to be a full answer, but here are some hints:
In order for a piece of code to run in parallel, all definitions it uses must be copied to the subkernels. This is called "distributing" the definitions and can be done manually by DistributeDefinitions
. It is also done automatically by most parallel functions (such as ParallelTable
). A notable exception was ParallelEvaluate
until version 10.4 .
Automatic distribution is done only for $Context
. This is controlled by $DistributedContexts
.
Why not distribute definitions for all contexts? Because for a package to work properly, it may not be sufficient to just copy all definitions from its context. The package may do things upon loading which are more complex than issuing definitions. E.g. it may load LibraryFunction
s. Thus packages are meant to be loaded on parallel kernels using ParallelNeeds
instead of just copying their definitions over from the main kernel.
What can you do then?
Either
DistributeDefinitions[const`precisionRate]
to manually distribute the definitions of this one symbol, or
$DistributedContexts := {$Context, "const`"}
to automatically distribute everything from the const`
context. The second solution looks cleaner to me.
Comments
Post a Comment