Skip to main content

manipulate - Variable scoping confusion


Forgive me if this question has been asked prior (I wouldn't even know where to start looking for an answer to this problem to be honest). I know the following code in Mathematica works:


temp = {x^2,Sin[x]}; (* Just a random list with functions inside *)
f = Function[x,Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
f[3]

The code would output the appropriate 9 as required. However, the problem occurs when I try to use a similar logic within a Manipulate function as shown below:


Manipulate[

Module[{temp,f},
temp = {x^2,Sin[x]};
f = Function[x,Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
{num, f[num]}],
{num, 3}]

Running the above code yields an output {3, x^2} and it doesn't change for any num. Any suggestions would be exceedingly helpful. For context as to why I'm doing this, I'm solving a differential equation within the Manipulate expression (where end conditions are manipulated by the controls). Using DSolve outputs the required functions in a list and I would simply like to graph them and their derivatives. If you know a better method of doing that, that would also be helpful.


Update


It appears that the problem is, in fact, with variable typing as shown below:


temp = {x^2, Sin[x]}; (*Just a random list with functions inside*)

f = Function[x, Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
f[3]
Manipulate[
Module[{temp, f},
temp = {x^2, Sin[x]};
f = Function[x, Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
{Head[temp], Head[f], Head[f[num]], Head[f[3]]}],
{num, 5}]
{Head[temp], Head[f], Head[f[3]]}


Note that the Head[f[num]] and Head[f[3]] within the Manipulate expression evaluate to Power whereas the Head[f[3]] outside evaluates to Integer (as expected). Using IntegerPart[] however still doesn't yield an appropriate answer. Any thoughts?



Answer



I misdiagnosed the problem originally, somehow assuming Manipulate was the culprit, when in fact it is Module, as @Kuba pointed out (thanks!). This is discussed in this Q&A:


Enforcing correct variable bindings and avoiding renamings for conflicting variables in nested scoping constructs


I would add that renaming the argument x to x$ in Function[x, Evaluate[body]] occurs whenever the body contains Module variables other than the Function argument(s).


Module[{temp, f},
temp = {x^2, Sin[x]};
f = Function[x, Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
f]
(* Function[x$, x^2] *)


However, no renaming occurs in the following, even though x is a Module variable: the argument stays x and perhaps unexpectedly, the instances of x in the body are not renamed to the Module variable x$746197, even though the expression is evaluated first. (This is discussed in "I define a variable as local to a module BUT then the module uses its global value! Why?")


Module[{temp, f, x},
f = Function[x, Evaluate[{x^2, Sin[x]}[[1]]]];
{x, f}]
(* {x$746197, Function[x, x^2]} *)

Original answer:


Under certain conditions, localized variables are changed when code is inserted into the localized body:


Manipulate[

Module[{temp, f},
temp = {x^2, Sin[x]};
f = Function[x, Evaluate[temp[[1]]]];
{num, f[num], f}],
{num, 3}]

Mathematica graphics


Note that the function argument has been changed to x$, which does not match the x in the body. I'm not sure why; "Manipulate is a strange beast" has been said before.


Try this:


Manipulate[

Module[{temp, f},
temp = {x^2, Sin[x]};
f = Function @@ {x, temp[[1]]};
{num, f[num], f}],
{num, 3}]

Mathematica graphics


Related:



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

front end - keyboard shortcut to invoke Insert new matrix

I frequently need to type in some matrices, and the menu command Insert > Table/Matrix > New... allows matrices with lines drawn between columns and rows, which is very helpful. I would like to make a keyboard shortcut for it, but cannot find the relevant frontend token command (4209405) for it. Since the FullForm[] and InputForm[] of matrices with lines drawn between rows and columns is the same as those without lines, it's hard to do this via 3rd party system-wide text expanders (e.g. autohotkey or atext on mac). How does one assign a keyboard shortcut for the menu item Insert > Table/Matrix > New... , preferably using only mathematica? Thanks! Answer In the MenuSetup.tr (for linux located in the $InstallationDirectory/SystemFiles/FrontEnd/TextResources/X/ directory), I changed the line MenuItem["&New...", "CreateGridBoxDialog"] to read MenuItem["&New...", "CreateGridBoxDialog", MenuKey["m", Modifiers-...

How to thread a list

I have data in format data = {{a1, a2}, {b1, b2}, {c1, c2}, {d1, d2}} Tableform: I want to thread it to : tdata = {{{a1, b1}, {a2, b2}}, {{a1, c1}, {a2, c2}}, {{a1, d1}, {a2, d2}}} Tableform: And I would like to do better then pseudofunction[n_] := Transpose[{data2[[1]], data2[[n]]}]; SetAttributes[pseudofunction, Listable]; Range[2, 4] // pseudofunction Here is my benchmark data, where data3 is normal sample of real data. data3 = Drop[ExcelWorkBook[[Column1 ;; Column4]], None, 1]; data2 = {a #, b #, c #, d #} & /@ Range[1, 10^5]; data = RandomReal[{0, 1}, {10^6, 4}]; Here is my benchmark code kptnw[list_] := Transpose[{Table[First@#, {Length@# - 1}], Rest@#}, {3, 1, 2}] &@list kptnw2[list_] := Transpose[{ConstantArray[First@#, Length@# - 1], Rest@#}, {3, 1, 2}] &@list OleksandrR[list_] := Flatten[Outer[List, List@First[list], Rest[list], 1], {{2}, {1, 4}}] paradox2[list_] := Partition[Riffle[list[[1]], #], 2] & /@ Drop[list, 1] RM[list_] := FoldList[Transpose[{First@li...

plotting - Magnifying Glass on a Plot

Although there is a trick in TEX magnifying glass but I want to know is there any function to magnifying glass on a plot with Mathematica ? For example for a function as Sin[x] and at x=Pi/6 Below, this is just a picture desired from the cited site. the image got huge unfortunately I don't know how can I change the size of an image here! Answer Insetting a magnified part of the original Plot A) by adding a new Plot of the specified range xPos = Pi/6; range = 0.2; f = Sin; xyMinMax = {{xPos - range, xPos + range}, {f[xPos] - range*GoldenRatio^-1, f[xPos] + range*GoldenRatio^-1}}; Plot[f[x], {x, 0, 5}, Epilog -> {Transparent, EdgeForm[Thick], Rectangle[Sequence @@ Transpose[xyMinMax]], Inset[Plot[f[x], {x, xPos - range, xPos + range}, Frame -> True, Axes -> False, PlotRange -> xyMinMax, ImageSize -> 270], {4., 0.5}]}, ImageSize -> 700] B) by adding a new Plot within a Circle mf = RegionMember[Disk[{xPos, f[xPos]}, {range, range/GoldenRatio}]] Show...