Skip to main content

simplifying expressions - How to find the most compact form of an equation


I would like to know whether there is any general approach to obtain the most compact form of an equation with Mathematica.


I used to believe that the FullSimplify command would do that for me, but I recently found out that it will not necessarily give the most compact form. I found out with the following equation, which has been FullSimplified:


$$\left[\sec (\alpha ) \left(\coth \left(L \sqrt{\text{Bo} \cos (\alpha )}\right)+\text{csch}\left(L \sqrt{\text{Bo} \cos (\alpha )}\right) (\text{Bo} L R \sin (\alpha )-1)-R \sin (\alpha ) \sqrt{\text{Bo} \sec (\alpha )}\right)\right]\left(R \sqrt{\text{Bo} \sec (\alpha )}\right)^{-1}$$


Or, in inputform for your convenience:



eq1 = (Sec[α] (Coth[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] - R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]] Sin[α] + 
Csch[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] (-1 + Bo L R Sin[α])))/(R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]])

However, if I now run the following:


Collect[eq1,Bo] //FullSimplify

I get a much more compact form, namely: $$ -\tan (\alpha )+L \sin (\alpha ) \sqrt{\text{Bo} \sec (\alpha )} \text{csch}\left(L \sqrt{\text{Bo} \cos (\alpha )}\right)+\frac{\tanh \left(\frac{1}{2} L \sqrt{\text{Bo} \cos (\alpha )}\right)}{R \sqrt{\text{Bo} \cos (\alpha )}}$$


Can someone explain why I get a more compact solution when I first collect the equation for a certain parameter and then run FullSimplify and whether there is a general 'recipe' to get the most compact form of an equation?


P.S. sorry for the long equation, but it seems that most of the smaller equations do not have this behaviour which makes sort of intuitive sense



Answer




There are at least two aspects to this. The first is the fact that FullSimplify will not try all possible transformations, even those it is aware of. See: Why does Simplify ignore an assumption? The second is that Mathematica does not see "compact" and "simple" as the same thing; if you give it a different ComplexityFunction it will do much better in this case. Compare:


eq1 = (Sec[α] (Coth[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] - R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]] Sin[α] + 
Csch[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] (-1 + Bo L R Sin[α])))/(R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]])

short1 = Collect[eq1, Bo] // FullSimplify


-Tan[α] + (
Sec[α] (Bo L R Csch[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] Sin[α] +
Tanh[1/2 L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]]))/(R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]])


short2 = FullSimplify[eq1, ComplexityFunction -> Composition[StringLength, ToString]]


(Csch[
L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] Sec[α] (-1 + Cosh[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] +
Bo L R Sin[α]))/(R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]]) - Tan[α]

The three expressions measured by both LeafCount and my ComplexityFunction:


LeafCount /@ {eq1, short1, short2}

Composition[StringLength, ToString] /@ {eq1, short1, short2}


{59, 51, 49}

{275, 374, 212}

Note that though short1 and short2 appear to be roughly the same length my ComplexityFunction sees short1 as being much longer. That is because it is not a very good metric, and it is using the OutputForm of the expression rendering "2D" text like this:


ToString[short1]



                                                               L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]
Sec[α] (Bo L R Csch[L Sqrt[Bo Cos[α]]] Sin[α] + Tanh[-----------------])
2
-Tan[α] + ------------------------------------------------------------------------
R Sqrt[Bo Sec[α]]

The point of all of this is that you need to be quite specific with ComplexityFunction if you want the expression simplified in the way you see as simple or compact.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

plotting - How to draw lines between specified dots on ListPlot?

I would like to create a plot where I have unconnected dots and some connected. So far, I have figured out how to draw the dots. My code is the following: ListPlot[{{1, 1}, {2, 2}, {3, 3}, {4, 4}, {1, 4}, {2, 5}, {3, 6}, {4, 7}, {1, 7}, {2, 8}, {3, 9}, {4, 10}, {1, 10}, {2, 11}, {3, 12}, {4,13}, {2.5, 7}}, Ticks -> {{1, 2, 3, 4}, None}, AxesStyle -> Thin, TicksStyle -> Directive[Black, Bold, 12], Mesh -> Full] I have thought using ListLinePlot command, but I don't know how to specify to the command to draw only selected lines between the dots. Do have any suggestions/hints on how to do that? Thank you. Answer One possibility would be to use Epilog with Line : ListPlot[ {{1, 1}, {2, 2}, {3, 3}, {4, 4}, {1, 4}, {2, 5}, {3, 6}, {4, 7}, {1, 7}, {2, 8}, {3, 9}, {4, 10}, {1, 10}, {2, 11}, {3, 12}, {4, 13}, {2.5, 7}}, Ticks -> {{1, 2, 3, 4}, None}, AxesStyle -> Thin, TicksStyle -> Directive[Black, Bold, 12], Mesh -> Full, Epilog -> { Line[ ...

list manipulation - Selecting multiple columns from a matrix?

Sample data: data = { {{2013, 1, 1}, 24.13, 167.67, 231.82}, {{2013, 1, 2}, 32.15, 170.92, 225.99}, {{2013, 1, 3}, 35.43, 172.68, 221.67}, {{2013, 1, 4}, 36.73, 173.05, 218.32}, {{2013, 1, 5}, 58.19, 165.96, 197.05}, {{2013, 1, 6}, 69.99, 163.50, 187.52}, {{2013, 1, 7}, 71.37, 154.21, 175.58}, {{2013, 1, 8}, 72.51, 149.66, 163.25}}; I want a DateListPlot with three graphs, so for a matrix formed by columns 1 and 2, one for columns 1 and 3, and 1 for columns 1 and 4. At the moment I'm using this code: data2 = Transpose[{data[[All, 1]], data[[All, 2]]}]; data3 = Transpose[{data[[All, 1]], data[[All, 3]]}]; data4 = Transpose[{data[[All, 1]], data[[All, 4]]}]; DateListPlot[{data2, data3, data4}, Joined -> True, Filling -> {3 -> {1}}] but I have a hunch that this can be done more efficiently. I don't like the Transpose s in particular. Any ideas? edit (for extra credit) What if I need to multiply the second column by 2, which in my solution is simp...

calculus and analysis - Integral of the Sinc product

Let us consider the following integral $$ B_n = \int_0^\infty \prod_{k=1,3,5,\dots}^n\frac{\sin (x/k)}{x/k}dx $$ By definition, Sinc[x] == Sin[x]/x , therefore B[n_?OddQ] := Integrate[Product[Sinc[x/k], {k, 1, n, 2}], {x, 0, Infinity}] B /@ Range[1, 13, 2] {Pi/2, Pi/2, Pi/2, Pi/2, Pi/2, Pi/2, Pi/2} OK, everything is fine. But... B[15] 467807924713440738696537864469 Pi/935615849440640907310521750000 What's going on? Answer As Eckhard wrote in comments B[n] is the n-th Borwein integral . (The letter B was not accidental :) ) This funny properties of Borwein integrals is related to the Fourier transform of Sinc function FourierTransform[Sinc[x], x, k] 1/2 Sqrt[Pi/2] (Sign[1 - k] + Sign[1 + k]) Plot[%, {k, -2, 2}, Filling -> 0] which is the box function. The result is $\pi/2$ while the sum $$ 1/3+1/5+\dots+1/n $$ B_n = \frac{\pi}{2} - \pi \bigg(\sum_{k=3,5,\ldots}^n\frac{1}{k} -1\biggr)^\frac{n-1}{2}\prod_{k=3,5,\dots}^n\frac{k}{k-1}. $$ For $n=15$ it is equal to $$ \frac{46780...