variable definitions - How to define a vector with automatically added symbolic elements with subscripts
I want to define a vector lets say k containing elements Symbolize[Subscript[k, 1]], k2, k3 ... etc. When I define lets say k4 . I want the symbol automatically added to vector k. Something like below but not working at all.
k /: {k, Symbolize[
ParsedBoxWrapper[
SubscriptBox[
StyleBox["v", FontFamily -> "Courier New", FontWeight -> "Plain",
FontSlant -> "Italic"], "_"]]]} :=
AppendTo[k, Subscript[v, _]];
My Question is;
1) How can I symbolically define elements (with sub scripts) automatically added to a vector.
2) If I assign values to symbols, How can I get elements values only and symbols only.
EDIT 1
Symbolize[Subscript[k, _]]
Command Symbolizes all subscripts of k e.g. k1 (Subscript[k, 1]
), k2 (Subscript[k, 2]
) etc. This is fine. What I want is collect k1, k2 k3 in a set (List) k with out additional commands or additional functions. Just as soon as sybolize sub scripted ones it should add it self to set k (sort of pattern maching as in Subscript[k, _]
). When I call k it should give me the list {k1, k2, k3}. @Mr. Wizards answer gives the list but as calling function ksym
. Sort of what I need but not exactly. @halirutan answer is also interesting but I don' t want to define additional functions or operators (may be as minimum as possible).
EDIT 2
Its sort of bag or set; no order is required, only k1,k3 can be given and k2 can be missing.
EDIT 3
<< Notation`
(*below line symbolizes all subscripted k_]*)
Symbolize[ ParsedBoxWrapper[
SubscriptBox["k", "_"]]]
somewhere here I need additional code that all k_ are added to k once its been defined. For example:
{Subscript[k, 1], Subscript[k, 2], Subscript[k, 3]} = {1, 2, 3}
after that when I ask k it should give me {Subscript[k, 1], Subscript[k, 2], Subscript[k, 3]}
as @Mr.Wizard suggested ksym[] := HoldForm @@@ UpValues[k][[All, 1]]
and for values kval[] := UpValues[k][[All, 2]]
should work. But, what I' m missing in @Mr.Wizard example is that one needs to define symbols as;
k /: Subscript[k, 1] = "val1";
k /: Subscript[k, 2] = "val2";
k /: Subscript[k, 3] = "val3";
what I need is once I write {Subscript[k, 1], Subscript[k, 2], Subscript[k, 3]} = {1, 2, 3}
I should be able to get k vector and {Subscript[k, 1], Subscript[k, 2], Subscript[k, 3]}
is appended automatically to k.
Answer
Method #1
If you define each Subscript using TagSet
(1)(2) the value will be associated with the Symbol, e.g. k
:
k /: Subscript[k, 1] = "val1";
k /: Subscript[k, 2] = "val2";
k /: Subscript[k, 3] = "val3";
You could then use definitions such as:
kval[] := UpValues[k][[All, 2]]
ksym[] := HoldForm @@@ UpValues[k][[All, 1]]
These will always be up to date as they are dynamically generated:
kval[]
{"val1", "val2", "val3"}
ksym[]
{k1, k2, k3}
Each "symbol" name is wrapped in HoldForm
to prevent evaluation; ReleaseHold
may be used to trigger it.
These definitions assume that no other UpValues
for k
are generated but if there are that can be addressed with pattern matching at the expense of speed.
Method #2
Following your update EDIT 3 here is another approach you might consider. Start by setting HoldFirst
on Subscript
so that k
may be used without forming an infinite recursion, then make a definition for k
that extracts the matching rules from the DownValues
list:
SetAttributes[Subscript, HoldFirst]
k := Cases[DownValues@Subscript, (_[x : Subscript[k, _]] :> _) :> Hold[x]]
Make some assignments and check k
:
{Subscript[k, 1], Subscript[k, 2], Subscript[k, 3]} = {"a", "b", "c"}
k
{Hold[Subscript[k, 1]], Hold[Subscript[k, 2]], Hold[Subscript[k, 3]]}
The subscripts are returned in held form, for further processing. One can use ReleaseHold
to recover the values:
k // ReleaseHold
{"a", "b", "c"}
Comments
Post a Comment